-
Key Lime Pie
Try our homemade Key Lime cream pie today! This pie is made with real key lime juice for a very tart delight. Available in a 9" and 6" graham cracker crust. Choose from whipped cream or meringue topping.
-
Lemon Pie
This refreshing Lemon Meringue pie is one of our bestselling cream pies. Best enjoyed with our old fashioned meringue recipe! Also available with our delicious whipped cream topping.
-
Peach Pie
We use fresh California peaches in our wonderful Peach Pie. You can’t beat our homemade filling made with real, fresh fruit-not that fake slurry filling! Choose from our double crust, delicious crumb topping, or fancy lattice crust.
-
Peanut Butter Chocolate Swirl Pie
Our Peanut Butter Chocolate Swirl Cream pie is made by layering our old fashioned peanut butter and chocolate pudding pie fillings. An amazing combination! Choose from whipped cream or meringue topping.
-
Peanut Butter Pie
Peanut butter mousse whipped up light and fluffy and topped with whipped cream and peanuts. There’s no way of resisting this Peanut Butter cream pie!
-
Pecan Pie
Pecan Pie is an old fashioned favorite. We use fresh cut pecans to make this a tasty treat. Our Pecan Pie can also be ordered with a layer of cream cheese that rises just under the pecans when baked.
-
Pineapple Pie
Try our Pineapple Pie filled with lots of sweet but tart pineapple chunks. This juicy, tropical taste cannot be beat! Choose from our double crust, delicious crumb topping, or fancy lattice crust.
-
Pumpkin Pie
This Pumpkin Pie is so good we had to make it available all year. Made with real pumpkins and flavored with cinnamon. Perfect for all your holiday parties! Our Pumpkin Pie can also be ordered with a layer of cream cheese right in between our flaky crust...
-
Red Raspberry Pie
Fresh ripe red raspberries make this special Red Raspberry Pie a treat! You can’t beat our homemade filling made with real fruit-not that fake slurry filling! Choose from our double crust, delicious crumb topping, or fancy lattice crust.
-
Rhubarb Pie
Available all year, we use fresh red rhubarb for a great sweet but tart flavor. Choose from our double crust, delicious crumb topping, or fancy lattice crust.
-
Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
This Strawberry Rhubarb Pie can’t be beat! We use fresh red rhubarb for a great sweet but tart flavor and mix in sweet strawberries. Yum! Choose from our double crust, delicious crumb topping, or fancy lattice crust.
-
Turtle Pie
Our Turtle Pie is made with a delicious light, rich, chocolate mousse and topped with whipped cream, chocolate and caramel drizzle, and pecans. A decadent treat!
Pies
Give someone that cozy holiday feeling any time of year with a fresh baked Mama Jo Pie. We offer more than 35 delicious flavors of pie and each is made fresh every day! The secret is in our light, flaky crust. You'll know our pie is real the moment you pick one up. We use real fruit, not that fake syrup or slurry filling. Our large Apple Pie weighs in at 4 pounds! Our pies are great desserts for family dinners, parties, corporate gifts, and when you need to satisfy your sweet tooth! Almost every pie is offered in three different sizes, allowing you to enjoy just the right amount. Try our famous Apple Pie, Lemon Meringue, Peanut Butter Pie, Pumpkin, or Pecan Pie. No matter what you desire, we have a pie flavor that is just right for you.
Best Pie
Best Dessert
2018, 2019, 2020, 2021
Readers Choice | The Morning Journal (Lorain, Ohio)